Biology · Molecular Basis of Inheritance
[Classic Experiment Problem Matrix — Meselson & Stahl]
[Classic Experiment Problem Matrix — Meselson & Stahl]
In Meselson and Stahl's experiment, E. coli bacteria grown in ¹⁵N medium were transferred to ¹⁴N medium and allowed to replicate for two generations:
(a) If DNA extraction after 40 minutes (two generations) showed 50% hybrid DNA and 50% light DNA, what percentage of hybrid vs light DNA would be observed after 60 minutes (three generations)?
(b) What would be the expected result after 3 generations if DNA replication were conservative instead of semi-conservative?
Try it in your notebook first, then use the hint or steps if you get stuck.
1
Hint 1
(a) After 3 generations (60 minutes), hybrid DNA decreases to 25% (1/4) and light DNA increases to 75% (3/4).
2
Hint 2
(b) Under a conservative model, parental heavy (¹⁵N–¹⁵N) DNA would remain permanently intact as a single heavy band alongside increasingly abundant light (¹⁴N–¹⁴N) DNA bands, with zero hybrid molecules formed. Final answer
(a) After 3 generations (60 minutes), hybrid DNA decreases to 25% (1/4) and light DNA increases to 75% (3/4).
(b) Under a conservative model, parental heavy (¹⁵N–¹⁵N) DNA would remain permanently intact as a single heavy band alongside increasingly abundant light (¹⁴N–¹⁴N) DNA bands, with zero hybrid molecules formed.
(b) Under a conservative model, parental heavy (¹⁵N–¹⁵N) DNA would remain permanently intact as a single heavy band alongside increasingly abundant light (¹⁴N–¹⁴N) DNA bands, with zero hybrid molecules formed.
Think first! Each hint opens after 45 seconds, one after another.
Hint: Read the question carefully and write down what is given and what is asked.
